You’ve got one night in Madison and you want it to be a beer night. Not a brewery-tour-all-day marathon — just one good evening that leaves you knowing the city a little better than when you arrived.
Here is the itinerary a Cicerone-led bar on Monroe Street would actually plan for you. Pick one production brewery for the early stop, eat real food, end at the bar with the deepest cooler.
5:30pm — Pick Your Production Brewery
You only have time for one brewery taproom tonight. Pick by what you want.
If You Want Downtown, Walkable, Lively
Working Draft Beer Company — 1129 E Wilson St.
Closer-in. Easy walk if you’re staying near the Capitol. The taproom skews modern American craft — hop-forward, lagers done right, mixed-ferm and barrel projects when the season suits. Hours: Mon–Thu 3–10, Fri–Sat 12–11, Sun 12–9.
If You Want Big Beers and Want to Pay Attention
Giant Jones Brewing — 931 E Main St (Suite 9).
Williamson-Marquette neighborhood. Independent, woman-owned, certified organic. Their thing is big beers — 7% ABV and up, the kind you sit with. If you only want a half-pour of something memorable, this is the stop. Tasting room hours: Wed 4–8, Thu 3–8, Fri 4–9, Sat 2–9, Sun 1–5. (Closed Mon & Tue.)
7:00pm — Eat Something Real
If you went to Giant Jones or Vintage Brewing, head toward Monroe Street.
If you went to Working Draft, you have more flexibility — but the night ends on Monroe Street anyway, so drift west.
Two dinner options that work for the timing:
- Pizza Brutta — 1805 Monroe St. Wood-fired Neapolitan. Personal pizzas, fast. Order one, eat it there or grab it to-go and walk it down the block.
- The Old Fashioned — 23 N Pinckney St (Capitol Square). Wisconsin supper-club energy, fish fry on Fridays, comfortable beer list to start your night with. About a fifteen-minute walk to Monroe Street after, or rideshare.
If you’d rather not stop for a proper dinner, the bring-your-own-food policy at the last stop means you can grab takeout from anywhere on Monroe Street and bring it with you.
8:30pm — End at Garth’s Brew Bar
Garth’s Brew Bar — 1726 Monroe St.
This is the deep-cooler stop. Sixteen rotating American craft taps. Two nitro draft taps for house cold brew coffee and tea. Ninety-five-plus craft cans and bottles in the cooler. Madison breweries first, Wisconsin next, independent American craft third. Beertenders study for or hold the Cicerone Beer Server certification.
What to do once you’re here:
- Tell the beertender where you went earlier. “I just came from Working Draft / Giant Jones / Vintage” gives them a calibration point. They’ll suggest something different — usually something from another Madison or Wisconsin brewery you wouldn’t have found on your own.
- Order one half-pour first. Tasting flights aren’t the only way to taste-test. A half-pour gives you full-pint context with the option to switch.
- Then open the cooler. The cooler is where the trip-defining beers live. Anything Wisconsin-only that you can’t get back home. Mix-and-match six-packs to take home are normal.
Three months after opening in December 2019, CraftBeer.com named Garth’s the Best Craft Beer Bar in Wisconsin. The cooler is the reason.
The Cicerone’s Honest Take on the Night
Two stops is the right number for one night. Three feels like work. The mistake first-time Madison visitors make is trying to hit four or five production breweries in a single evening — you don’t taste anything, you’re full of carbonation, and you don’t remember a beer by morning.
Pick one production brewery for context. Eat a real meal. End somewhere with the breadth to send you home knowing one Wisconsin beer you didn’t know existed before tonight.
That’s the trip.
FAQ
What if I only have an hour, not a night?
Skip everything above. Walk into Garth’s, order a half-pour of whatever Madison brewery just landed, and ask the beertender what’s on the wall you couldn’t get back home. Leave knowing one beer. That’s a worthwhile hour.
Is rideshare the right move for this itinerary?
Yes. Working Draft is near-downtown, Giant Jones is Williamson, Vintage is west-side, and Garth’s is Monroe Street. You’ll cross town once or twice. Rideshare cost over the night is in the $20–35 range from a downtown hotel. Walking from Working Draft to the Capitol Square + a rideshare to Monroe Street is also reasonable.
Can I do this itinerary on a Monday?
No — Giant Jones is closed Mon & Tue, and Garth’s is closed Mondays as well. Tuesday is also tight (Garth’s opens 5pm and hosts trivia, Giant Jones is closed). Wednesday through Sunday all work.
What if I’m here for a UW football Saturday?
The pre-game / post-game dynamics change everything. There’s a separate route for that — see Craft Beer Near Camp Randall.
One comment
Pingback: What to Drink in Madison This Week (Updated Monthly)