Award
Best Craft Beer Bar in Wisconsin
— CraftBeer.com, March 2020 (3 months after opening)
— CraftBeer.com, March 2020 (3 months after opening)
Real reviews from real Madison neighbors and out-of-town visitors. Pulled directly from Google. Names, dates, and the lot — because that’s the part that matters.
★★★★★
“As a Christmas gift for some close friends, I booked a beer tasting led by Garth himself. Garth couldn’t have been easier to work with. He asked a few questions about the kinds of beers we liked and he took it from there. Garth is super knowledgeable and a great storyteller. I couldn’t recommend him enough to anyone who wanted a personal, well thought out personalized beer tasting. Long live Garth’s!”
★★★★★
“This place is great! They have so many beers to choose from as well as options for non-beer lovers like the slushies which are always so great! Lots of seating, a great spot to meet up with friends. The giant pretzel is delicious!”
★★★★★
“We stopped here both before and after a football game a few weeks ago. It’s a great place with a great mix of drinks for everyone’s preferences. If one of their on-tap brews don’t interest you they also have a reach-in cooler to grab a can of something. Great atmosphere.”
★★★★★
“Absolutely incredible beer bar! Garth has 18 beers on tap (most from Wisconsin), but if you don’t like any of those, there are dozens more available by the can or bottle. Casual, laid-back atmosphere, including outdoor seating. All tap beers are available in 4 oz portions, enabling you to create your own flight. This is a must-visit if you’re in Madison.”
★★★★★
“Had a wonderful time at Garth’s Brew Bar with great service, nice atmosphere and excellent selection of anything-but-ordinary beer. Tim the beertender was helpful, knowledgeable and shared specific information that made it a more personalized experience. We were a crew of Polish people and Tim brought out a beer he thought we’d like from Polish hops. Really cool. Will definitely come back next time we’re in town!”
★★★★★
“My dad and I had a great time. First time in Madison and this was our only stop on the way to Milwaukee! We were just going to get a snack and enjoy the town, but we were having such a good time we had a few drinks and stayed 3 hours. Tim was such a wonderful host providing pleasant conversation and great service. 10/10 great place. We will be back!”
★★★★★
“The passion for beer that runs through this place is palpable. Garth’s creates an environment where you can earnestly connect with others and revel in the company. The owner, Garth, is a Cicerone (sommelier of the beer world) who is not only knowledgeable, but overjoyed and friendly as well. If you enjoy beer, go to Garth’s and you’ll find new levels to discover.”
★★★★★
“Garth and his staff are fantastic! They have a beer for everyone. I love sour beer and they always have some great options for me to enjoy. Tuesday night trivia is a blast. I love that I can grab beer to take home, too. Garth’s is just a great, low-key neighborhood hangout.”
★★★★★
“Very nice atmosphere, super-clean restrooms, and delicious beers on tap. Lead Bartender Tim was exceptionally friendly, and took really great care of us while we were there.”
★★★★★
“First time visit, we just came for drinks, so didn’t try any food, but pizza, pretzels, and chips available for purchase. Fun, laid back atmosphere. Found easy street parking right outside.”
Visited recently?
If you had a great time, leaving a Google review is the single best thing you can do for a small Madison business. If something was off — let us know first so we can make it right.
Plan Your Visit
1726 Monroe St, Madison, WI 53711 · Walk-in only · No phone
Tue–Thu: 5–9 pm
Friday: 4–10 pm
Saturday: 12–10 pm
Sunday: 12–7 pm
Monday: Closed