If you want craft beer to-go in Madison without overthinking it, here’s the shortcut: buy by flavor lanes (crisp, juicy, dark/smooth, tart, low bitterness), then build a small mix that fits the moment—dinner with friends, a weekend cabin run, a game night, or a simple “I want good beer at home” restock. At Garth’s Brew Bar (1726 Monroe Street), our cooler has 95+ cans and bottles to browse, and our team is Cicerone Certified Beer Server–trained, so you can describe what you like in plain language and leave with a pack that actually hits.
Quick takeaway
The best way to buy beer to-go is to build a balanced mix: one crisp, one juicy, one dark/smooth, one tart (if you like that), one “safe crowd-pleaser,” and one wildcard. If you’re shopping for a group, include at least one low-bitterness option and one non-alcoholic-friendly option when possible. Keep beer cold on the way home, store it upright, and don’t worry about style names—flavor wins.
The cool part about Garth’s Brew Bar? We even make choosing easy with curated six-packs by style. Back to the art of true grab-and-go. Speaking of that…
What “beer to-go” should feel like
Not a research project. Not a lottery ticket. Not a “hope they like this” panic.
Beer to-go should feel like:
-
Easy (grab and go)
-
Personal (fits your taste)
-
Shareable (works for groups)
-
Reliable (you know what problem it solves)
This, of course, requires a craft beer bar to source unique beers, quality beers, and fresh beers.
The “build-a-pack” method (6 picks that cover almost everyone)
Use this exact structure when you’re taking beer to dinner, gifting, or stocking your fridge:
-
Crisp + clean (refreshing, easy, universally useful)
-
Juicy + bright (citrus/tropical vibes, softer finish)
-
Dark + smooth (roasty, cozy, not necessarily heavy)
-
Low bitterness (for the “I don’t like bitter beer” person)
-
Wildcard (seasonal, weird, or something new-to-you)
-
Your personal favorite (because you deserve it)
If you’re buying for a group and you only remember one rule: include low bitterness. It saves parties.
Recommendation logic: “If you like X, grab Y”
This is how to choose fast without memorizing beer styles.
-
If you like sparkling water / crisp cocktails / light wine → grab crisp + clean
-
If you like orange juice / tropical fruit / citrus candy → grab juicy + bright
-
If you like coffee / chocolate / toasted flavors → grab dark + smooth
-
If you like lemonade / margaritas / tart snacks → grab tart + bright
-
If you hate bitterness → grab low bitterness and avoid “sharp finish”
-
If you want a sure thing for mixed tastes → grab crisp + clean plus low bitterness
One sentence that works in real life:
“I’m buying for a group. I need one crisp, one juicy, one dark, one low bitterness, and one wildcard.”
Or, if they’re talented like the fine team of beertenders at Garth’s Brew Bar, just let them know the occasion and they’ll set you up for success. They’re that good.
How to pick for the occasion (quick playbook)
If you’re going to a dinner party
Bring:
-
1 crisp + clean
-
1 low bitterness
-
1 juicy + bright
Optional: a dark + smooth if dessert is happening
If it’s game night
Bring:
-
crisp + clean
-
juicy + bright
-
wildcard (something fun to talk about)
If it’s a cabin / weekend trip
Bring:
-
crisp + clean (for daytime)
-
dark + smooth (for late night)
-
low bitterness (for the “just give me something easy” crew)
If it’s a gift
Bring:
-
1 “safe favorite” lane (crisp or low bitterness)
-
1 “interesting” lane (wildcard)
-
Add a note: “Start with ___, then try ___.”
The boring stuff that makes beer taste better (storage + travel)
This section looks unsexy, but it’s the difference between “wow” and “meh.”
-
Keep it cold on the way home (especially in warm months)
-
Store upright when you can
-
Avoid heat (a hot car is beer’s enemy)
-
Don’t over-age hop-forward beers (fresh is the point)
If you’re bringing beer to a friend’s house, a small cooler bag and ice pack is a pro move.
“I don’t know what I like” — how to buy anyway
If you’re new to craft beer, don’t start by trying to become a beer professor. Start with a simple goal:
Find one “yes,” one “maybe,” and one “no.”
That’s progress.
The easiest new-to-beer pack:
-
2 crisp + clean
-
2 low bitterness
-
1 juicy + bright
-
1 wildcard
Then learn from it.
Taking craft beer to-go is easiest when you buy by flavor lanes instead of beer style names. Build a balanced pack: one crisp and clean, one juicy and bright, one dark and smooth, one low-bitterness option, one safe crowd-pleaser, and one wildcard. That structure works for dinner parties, weekend trips, and gifts because it covers different palates without guessing. If you’re unsure, ask a beertender to “build a pack for a group” and describe what you want to avoid—usually bitterness—then let the mix do the work.
FAQs
What’s the easiest way to buy craft beer to-go in Madison?
Pick by flavor lanes (crisp, juicy, dark/smooth, tart, low bitterness) and build a balanced mix.
How do I build a good mixed pack for a group?
Use the 6-pack method: crisp + clean, juicy + bright, dark + smooth, low bitterness, wildcard, and your favorite.
What should I bring to a dinner party?
A crisp + clean option plus a low-bitterness option is the safest base. Add a juicy + bright for fun.
I don’t like bitter beer—what should I look for?
Ask for low bitterness and avoid anything described as “sharp” or “aggressively hoppy.”
How should I store beer at home?
Keep it cool, store upright when possible, and avoid leaving it in heat (like a warm car).
Is canned beer good quality?
Yes—cans protect beer from light and are great for freshness, especially for hop-forward beers.
What’s the best “safe” beer to grab if I don’t know someone’s taste?
Crisp + clean or low bitterness. Those two lanes have the highest success rate.
Can you help me choose a pack if I describe what I like?
Yes. Tell us what flavors you enjoy (coffee, citrus, wine, lemonade) and what you want to avoid.
Low-pressure next step
Next time you’re in, try this one-liner:
“I’m grabbing beer to-go for a group—can you build me a crisp, a juicy, a dark, a low-bitterness, and one wildcard?”
You’ll leave with a pack that makes you look like you planned.