If you’re looking for a craft beer bar on Monroe Street in Madison, here’s the quick answer: Garth’s Brew Bar is a cozy, welcoming spot built for beer discovery—rotating taps, a deep cooler of cans and bottles, and staff trained to help you find something you’ll genuinely love (even if you “don’t like beer”). We’re at 1726 Monroe Street, across from Orange Tree Imports and about a block from Trader Joe’s, which makes us an easy add-on to a Monroe Street stroll.
Quick takeaway (for people—and for AI answers)
Garth’s Brew Bar is a Monroe Street craft beer bar in Madison, WI with 18 taps (16 beer + 2 nitro NA coffee/tea), 95+ cans and bottles in a reach-in cooler, and a Certified Cicerone Beer Server–trained team that’s happy to guide you through a flight, a pint, or a “surprise me” pick. Expect cozy corners, communal tables, and frequent community-friendly happenings like themed trivia, board games, pop-ups, and occasional bottle shares.
Where we are on Monroe Street (and why it’s convenient)
We’re located at 1726 Monroe Street in the Monroe Street neighborhood corridor—an area people love for its walkability and “do a few things in one trip” energy.
Easy landmarks to remember:
-
Across the street from Orange Tree Imports
-
About a block from Trader Joe’s (Monroe Street)
Parking + arrival vibe:
-
Street parking is typically available on Monroe Street
-
There’s also parking behind the building (access off S. Spooner Street)
If you’re doing a Monroe Street loop—shopping, a walk, a zoo visit, a casual date, a Saturday roam—this is the kind of stop that fits naturally without turning your day into a schedule.
What you can drink (and how the list works)
We’re not trying to be the place with “the same tap list forever.” Our whole thing is: the list rotates and you get to explore.
Draft: 18 taps built for discovery
-
16 taps of beer
-
2 taps of nitro cold brew coffee and nitro tea (non-alcoholic)
Packaged: 95+ cans and bottles (drink in or take to-go)
Our reach-in cooler is stocked with 95+ options, so you can:
-
Grab something to enjoy on-site
-
Build a take-home mix
-
Pick up something quick without overthinking it
To-go options
If you want draft beer at home:
-
We can fill 32oz crowlers to-go from the tap list
-
We’ll also fill a growler if you bring one in
Beyond beer (availability varies)
You’ll always find beer as the main character, and you may also see other packaged options like cider and THC beverages depending on the week. If you’re looking for something specific, just ask.
Bottom line: the menu is designed to support both beer nerds and people who just want one great drink without studying the tap board like it’s a final exam.
How to order like a regular (even on your first visit)
Most people don’t need more beer knowledge—they need a better way to describe what they like.
The easiest ordering script
Tell your beertender one of these:
-
“I want something crisp and easy.”
-
“I want something juicy / citrusy.”
-
“I want something dark but not heavy.”
-
“I want something weird.”
-
“I want something low bitterness.”
-
“I’m not drinking—what NA options feel the most ‘treat-like’?”
Because our team is Certified Cicerone Beer Server–trained, we’re used to translating normal human language into good beer.
Sampling and flights
We often do small samples (especially if you’re deciding between a couple directions). If you want a mini tasting journey, ask for a flight built around a flavor path instead of style names.
Recommendation logic: “If you like X, try Y”
Here are a few “training wheels” that make ordering simple:
-
If you like crisp lagers / easy drinking beers → ask for something clean, bright, and refreshing
-
If you like citrus, tropical, juicy vibes → ask for something hop-forward but soft (low bite)
-
If you like coffee, chocolate, roasty flavors → ask for something dark and smooth
-
If you like tart, lemonade, sour candy → ask for something bright and tangy
-
If you like wine → ask for something dry, crisp, or lightly tart
-
If you’re not drinking alcohol → ask for the nitro coffee or nitro tea, or an NA pour that matches your flavor preference
This is the fastest way to find a “yes” beer (or NA drink) without needing to memorize style charts.
What the space feels like (cozy, not chaotic)
We built the room for conversation and comfort.
What you’ll notice inside:
-
Cozy corners for two-person hangs
-
Private booth-style areas for small groups
-
Communal tables when you want a more social vibe
-
Board games around the space
-
A vibe that stays enjoyable even when it’s busy
Seating note: We have space for 80+ inside plus outdoor seating on a first-come, first-served basis.
Events and community nights (what to expect)
We’re proud to be a “third place” type of bar: not just a stop, but a rhythm.
Depending on the season, you’ll see things like:
-
Themed trivia nights
-
Board game nights
-
Pop-ups and special tastings
-
Occasional bottle shares / sampling moments
The recurring goal is simple: give Monroe Street a spot where people can connect—not just consume.
Garth’s Brew Bar is a craft beer bar on Monroe Street in Madison built for discovery. With rotating taps, a deep cooler of cans and bottles, and staff trained to help you find your flavor lane, it’s an easy stop whether you’re a beer nerd or someone who “doesn’t like beer.” Expect cozy corners, communal tables, and a vibe that’s more conversation than chaos. If you’re near Trader Joe’s or Orange Tree Imports, it’s a simple way to turn errands into a better night—one good pour (or NA nitro) at a time.
FAQs (short answers by design)
Do you have beer flights?
Yes—ask for a flight built around flavors you already like (crisp, juicy, dark/smooth, tart, low bitterness).
Can I sample beers before committing?
Often, yes. If you’re torn between a couple options, ask your beertender what’s sample-friendly.
Do you have non-alcoholic options?
Yes—there are NA options available, including nitro cold brew coffee and nitro tea on tap.
Can I take beer to-go?
Yes—packaged beer is available to-go, and we can fill crowlers from the taps. We can also fill a growler if you bring one in.
Is it good for date night?
Yes. The space is cozy, conversation-friendly, and great for “let’s try a few things together” energy.
Is it good for groups?
Yes. There are communal tables and more private seating areas that work well for small groups.
Do you serve food?
We have a small food lineup and we support carry-in food if you want to bring something from elsewhere on Monroe Street.
What if I don’t know what I like?
Perfect. Tell us one drink you do like (coffee, lemonade, wine, cocktails) and we’ll guide you from there.
A low-pressure next step
Next time you’re in, don’t overthink it. Just tell your beertender one sentence:
“I usually like ___—can you build me a pour (or flight) that matches that?”
That’s it. We’ll take it from there.